Categories
Anime Reviews First Impressions Reviews

Spring 2021 First Impressions – Koikimo

Streaming: Crunchyroll

Episodes: TBA

Source: Manga

Story Summary: Ryo Amakusa is an attractive businessman (and a known womanizer), but he finds most of the women around him to be tiresome and annoying. One morning he nearly falls down a staircase on his way to work, but is snagged by his collar at the last moment by a high school girl. Later that day Ryo discovers that this girl, Ichika, is his younger sister Rio’s friend when he meets her again at their apartment. That’s when the “fun” begins. Ryo becomes infatuated with Ichika, because she doesn’t fawn over him like the adult women he encounters at work and on the street. “By chance” the two keep encountering one-another and Ryo’s persistence doesn’t seem as though it will wane, much to Ichika’s distress. In Ryo’s case, “no” means “keep bothering her until she changes her mind.”

Impressions: So, I don’t know how many of you out there enjoy cooking, but one thing I enjoy making from time-to-time are home-made hamburgers. There’s just something nice about being able to season the meat the way you want it and to cook it to perfection (whatever that means to you). But one thing about cooking, especially with raw, somewhat fatty meat, is that the act of searing in the deliciousness results in some less-than-tasty by-products. The grease left on your pan is something you have to deal with but which you generally wipe up and throw in the garbage, leaving behind nothing but a delicious meal. Perhaps some of you might have seen 2018’s After the Rain, a story that begins with a high school student harboring a crush on her much older boss. There are moments of discomfort before you realize that the story isn’t meant to be an age-gap romance, but rather a parallel story of two different people taking inspiration from one-another in their effort to move on from hardship. If After the Rain is the hamburger, then Koikimo is the grease, the inedible garbage leftover from something well-cooked; something that if you consume it, it’s bound to make you throw up.

I can only guess how many people reading this review may have found themselves in a situation where they were romantically pursued, seemingly out of the blue, by someone to whom they weren’t also attracted. It happened to me many years ago, so let me try to convey through a story just how uncomfortable it is. A fellow student of mine at my high school got my phone number from someone and started calling me after school on the daily. I thought he just wanted to be friends because we both liked video games and it wasn’t like we’d never spoken in person, so I would talk with him to be nice. It was after that where things started to become really uncomfortable. He bought me flowers and some small piece of jewelry; I didn’t know what to do with them and felt completely cornered and vulnerable by that point. “Consent” was not the known concept that it is now, and I felt trapped into “being nice” and “giving him a chance” because he’d spent money on me, even though (at least in my eyes) the chemistry clearly wasn’t there. I was afraid to tell him to buzz off because I was afraid of prompting a violent response, even though at that time I don’t think I could have directly articulated that and just simply felt nervous about what could happen. I went out on one date with him, and it was one of the more memorably uncomfortable moments of my life. I’d been working at my cashier job all day and spent the evening trying to summon the energy to deal with this one date while my throat was dry and all I could do was cough and cough while choking on the conversation. Thinking about it still makes me cringe. I was lucky that it seemed to finally come to an end after that.

Watching this episode, watching Ichika struggle with unwanted attention from a grown adult man, brought those tense, nauseating feelings rushing back to me. Because while I’ve been in the position of dealing with unwanted attention and gifts as I’ve mentioned, I’ve also been in the position of being victimized by an adult man many years my senior. And in this show, that seems to be a joke worth telling, again and again and again. I don’t know why, in this day and age, this story of a man stalking and harassing a girl is being framed as a comedy, but I suppose there’s just no explanation for some things.

Also, Rio, Ryo’s younger sister and “friend” to Ichika, is an enabler. Gross.

Pros: You know, I almost always try to find something positive about the things that I watch, but I’m having a really difficult time with this one.

Cons: This cutely-portrayed story of an adult stalking a teenage child just feels gross all-around. I often lament the fact that there are storytellers who seem completely oblivious to the kind of pain people have to deal with when living their lives. While I strongly believe in people’s right to tell the stories they want to tell, I also believe in my right to criticize them for missing the mark, and this is one of those times. It just sucks when your personal pain gets trivialized, and I suspect I’m not the only one who feels this way toward this story.

Content Warnings: Mild sexual imagery. Stalking. Harassment through giving unwanted gifts and making unwanted phone calls. Age-gap relationship. Grooming behavior (and adults failing to identify it).

Would I Watch More? – No, I find this concept pretty vile, and I don’t feel the need to upset myself on a weekly basis.

9 replies on “Spring 2021 First Impressions – Koikimo”

It’s not often that an anime makes me uncomfortable. I’m glad to know that it wasn’t just me that was struggling to find good things to say about this first episode.

I like to imagine myself as being mostly unaffected by most material by this point in my life; even a lot of the material I find bothersome is stuff I can separate myself from and critique from some distance, but every once-in-a-while… I think we all have personal bad experiences that just get poked at directly sometimes.

It always bugs the heck out of me when it seems like the Japanese culture thinks it is perfectly ok for older men, even middle aged men, to pursue teenage girls. The power differential is too great. Girls don’t exist merely to serve the appetites of insecure guys.

Swapping the genders doesn’t make it better but it is something you almost never see in anime.

I’d argue that it’s unfortunately not limited to some idiosyncrasy of Japanese culture; I think unhealthy relationships (and specifically older people grooming younger people) exist everywhere. It just seems to be anime/manga in particular that has a lot of obvious examples for those of us in the otaku sphere. There’s a BuzzFeed article floating around which features several examples of what it describes as “questionable” age-gap relationships among Hollywood folks, and while I don’t want to say large age-gaps are impossible to make work, I also wonder what exactly the (often, but not always) older men in these relationships think that they’re doing. But yeah, it’s definitely a concerning power differential and I can’t deny that there are people who are attracted to that dynamic. It’s just when you get into stalking and (potentially) statutory rape territory that one wonders what’s actually supposed to be entertaining in the scenario?

https://www.buzzfeed.com/shelbyheinrich/celebrity-couples-who-had-questionable-age-differences

You can handle the age-gap romance with sensitivity. As a example I suggest The Garden of Words by Shinkai. It is still my favorite anime by him. Contract that with the idiocy of Domestic Girlfirend.

Or even Golden Kamuy. Most of the time it is a fun romp through thru the Japanese north. Nudity? So what?. Everyone in the show could be naked all the time and I wouldn’t care.

But there are a couple of scenes where the squick factor skyrockets. Fanservice included to grab the attention of a pedophile. It bothers me. It sets off all my daddy alarms.

I could not count the number of times lolis are set up as sexual objects. How not to Summon a Demon Lord is full of it. Other times they do the “loli is really an ancient and powerful entity who just happens to look and act like a sexually precocious 8 year old” trope. World Conquest Zvezda Plot, anyone?

You’d never see this in mainstream media in the US. Here we at least generally accept that little children are not appropriate targets of sexual desire and that one should NEVER act on such a desire.

I did a blog about this:
https://aunatural.org/2020/01/12/the-aspect-of-japanese-culture-i-find-most-disturbing/

I think you may have mistaken me – I think that we generally agree on these points. One of my most hated tropes is “she’s actually an 800-year-old-vampire” because, like so many things in entertainment, it’s an internal excuse for an external criticism (e.g. our issue is “sexualizing child-like bodies is gross,” so it doesn’t matter that the character is a chronological adult/over the age of consent in the context of the show).

But, I’m going to have to reiterate that I don’t think that this is a Japan-only issue, however it’s an issue that manifests very differently in America/the West and may not feel directly equivalent. Many of the casting choices made in films with romantic couplings place older men aside sometimes significantly (and occasionally, actually underage) women/girls. I don’t know if it’s because of the lingering cultural perception that women shrivel up at age 30 (if so, I must be a raisin, lol!) but there are lots of examples of this. It’s basically Woody Allen’s M.O. (which… let’s not get started about that guy). It’s definitely not to the level of literal pre-pubescent children being cast as romantic leads, but these sort of casting decisions must surely contribute to the idea of “precocious sexuality” (“she came on to me!”) that has harmed young women when bringing forth sexual assault accusations against adult predators. And to be honest, I can’t watch some middle-aged man mack on a barely (or non) legal woman and not be reminded of things that have happened to me in the past, so this argument is personal, as well. Youth-worship and a feeling of entitlement to girls’/women’s bodies are a symptom of this problem.

Once again, sorry for the BuzzFeed link, but their dang listicles just manage to collect a lot of useful information in one place sometimes- https://www.buzzfeed.com/spenceralthouse/messed-up-actor-age-gaps-movies-and-tv

Again, I’m not trying to discount the fact that CP is a problem in Japan or claim that lolicon isn’t an issue (while I don’t believe in censorship of art and don’t believe that gross drawings are equivalent to real-life harm, I definitely agree I don’t want to have anything to do with it); I’m not into the “this is just another culture” defense because I think aspects of a culture that actively harm people/uphold harmful attitudes are not worth defending. They don’t treat CP as a serious offense there (as you note in your post). But I’m extending this line of thinking to American culture as well, because there are similar problems here. Child marriage is unfortunately legal (through workarounds) in most US states still. Barf.

Thank you for mentioning “The Garden of Words.” I’ve seen and enjoyed it. That said, the difference between the characters’ ages, or more so their stages of life still squicks me, especially since the woman is/was an authority figure to the boy.

If you’re comfortable sharing, I’d be interested in knowing which scenes from “Golden Kamuy” were troubling for you; I absolutely love the show and have watched it a few times and I’m not recalling of anything of that nature. I’d like to be able to content warn for them in the future.

Thank you for your comment, and I hope this makes sense even if we may not be perfectly-aligned on every nuance of the conversation.

There’s scene where they are attacked while they are all naked in a hot spring. Obviusly an excuse the have a bunch of naked men running around and fighting. OK fine. I’ve been in hot springs which a large group of people of all genders and ages and we were all nude and no big deal.

But… now adult male is tightly holding a young boy while they hide from pursuers. (The kid’s name literally means “boner”.) and explaining what a “boner” is. Why would you need to do that right then? The quick factor went thru the roof.

There were a couple of other scenes that I can’t remember that were squicky but not as bad. I wonder if it got edited along the way….

I didn’t see her as an authority figure to him. She certainly didn’t act authoritatively. I got the feeling they backed off because they realized they both needed to mature a bit before anything serious happened. I think of that as a very good outcome.

He wants to become stronger so they can meet each other as equals. That said, Takao is 15 and Yukina is 27. When he hits 18 she will be 30. If the feelings are still strong at that time, I’d have a tough time objecting to the relationship.

The important thing to me is that he is not being portrayed as a sex object and she has extreme reservations about him getting too close.

Interestingly, I didn’t find that part in “Golden Kamuy” upsetting, because I felt that it fit right in with the juvenile boner-humor of the show and the context made it clear (to me) that the young character wasn’t being sexualized or being threatened sexually…

But I think with your comments you’ve brought us back around to an interesting point – that of internal versus external objections to content in media. For me, despite the fact that the relationship between the student and teacher in “The Garden of Words” is provided context, and sensitively so (Shinkai does in 45 minutes what a lot of storytellers wish they could do in 12 episodes, honestly), it’s not a lack of context or reasoning that I find objectionable – it’s an external objection I have to the situation: the thought of a 27-year-old teacher and a 15-year-old student in an relationship that, on paper, is at least emotionally inappropriate considering their ages and positions in society, is concerning to me on some level that context will likely never be able to touch, no matter how much more

Likewise, I can probably talk all day about how I think all the juvenile dick and boner jokes in GK leading up to the hot springs episode provide an internal explanation for why the nudity in that episode isn’t meant to be sexual (except as fanservice for viewers who like attractive male characters), but any explanation I give isn’t going to change the fact that the way you feel about it has nothing to do with the internal reasoning the show provides, but is instead an external objection that’s much larger than a few scenes in one anime series, and based on your own feelings and experience.

I hope I didn’t mischaracterize anything on your end!

I think this is a great reminder of what I love about anime fandom and the aniblogging community – the diversity of opinion. I often go through periods where I wonder if putting my writing out there is worthwhile, because I think overall there are a lot of things that the fandom tends to skew one way or the other about (or maybe that’s just me seeing trends in the “big” voices in the fandom). But there are also places where we differ, and I enjoy hearing about those things so I don’t get too comfortable in my assumptions.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.